PMProCo Picks

Home › The Holiday Baker › Guides

Bread Baking at Home: The Tools That Actually Matter

Mixing, proofing, scoring and baking: the four jobs that matter for home bread, and the tools that do each one well, from a first loaf to regular sourdough.

Bread needs fewer tools than you think

Home bread baking looks complicated from the outside, but the tool list is short: something to mix in, something to proof in, something to score with, and something to bake in. Everything else is a refinement. This guide walks through the four jobs in order, so you can buy in stages and bake your first loaf without a cupboard full of gear.

Mixing and kneading

Most bread starts in a bowl with a spoon or a whisk, and that is genuinely enough for a first loaf. A Danish dough whisk, included in several of the kits below, cuts through stiff dough more easily than a spoon and cleans up faster than a mixer attachment. When you start baking weekly, a stand mixer earns its place: the KitchenAid Artisan Series 5 Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer kneads dough with its dough hook while your hands stay free, and the 5-quart bowl handles a standard batch. A hand mixer cannot knead bread dough, so do not buy one for that job — it is for batters and cream, not dough.

Proofing: give the loaf its shape

A banneton is a basket that supports dough while it rises, giving the loaf its shape and a light pattern on the crust. Rattan is the traditional material because it wicks a little moisture from the dough surface, which helps the crust. The Bread Art Banneton Proofing Basket Set is a good first kit: a round basket, a silicone sling, scrapers, a whisk and a lame in one box. If you want both loaf shapes, the Gnyonat Bread Proofing Basket Set adds an oval basket for batards. The EWFEN Sourdough Proofing Basket Gift Set covers the same ground and works well as a gift. Prefer easy cleaning? The ZJFTERJY Silicone Sourdough Starter Kit uses silicone baskets that rinse clean and do not need careful drying. Whichever you choose, dust the basket with flour before each use and let it dry fully between bakes.

Scoring: the cut that controls the rise

Scoring is the slash across the top of the loaf before baking. It is not decoration for its own sake: it tells the loaf where to expand, so it opens cleanly instead of bursting at a weak spot. A bread lame — a razor on a handle — makes a clean, shallow cut that a kitchen knife often drags through. Most of the kits above include one with spare blades. Keep the blade sharp, hold it at a low angle, and make one confident cut rather than several hesitant ones.

Baking: the Dutch oven method

The single biggest upgrade to home bread is baking inside a preheated Dutch oven. The heavy lid traps the steam the loaf gives off, and that steam keeps the crust soft while the loaf expands, then crisps as the steam escapes. The Lodge 5-Quart Double Dutch Oven is a strong pick because its lid doubles as a skillet. For a lower-cost start, the Amazon Basics Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6 Quart does the same job without seasoning. A silicone bread sling, included in the kits above, lowers the dough into the hot pot safely and lifts the finished loaf out.

Starting a sourdough starter

If you want to try sourdough, you need a jar for the starter as well as the tools above. The KOACKL Sourdough Bread Starter Kit includes a starter jar alongside its basket, whisk, lame and sling, which makes it a tidy one-box start. Feed the starter regularly, keep it somewhere warm, and bake with it once it reliably doubles after feeding. Your first loaves will not be perfect, and that is normal — bread baking improves fast with practice. See the full bread collection on The Holiday Baker home page to compare the kits side by side.

Picks from this guide

Back to The Holiday Baker